← Back to Technical Trading Scorecard
TECHNICAL TRADING SCORECARD

CMS

CMS Energy
$70.00
Tue, Nov 3, 2026 close (weekly items: Fri, Oct 30)
USFL alternative · entry card
AVOIDAvoid for now: Trend Down and Friday close below a falling 40-wk SMA ($72.78). Re-check when the trend repairs.

Action levels

Buy zone (breakout retest)——no confirmed breakout, so no retest zone
Profit-Taking Zone$73.12–75.06+4.5% to +7.2%61.8% retr., wk high ’25-08-22, wk low 03-20
Trading stop · daily closebelow $67.71-3.3%trading downgrade
Trend stop · Friday closebelow $63.97-8.6%trend downgrade one state
Breakout Buy Levelclose above $72.78+4.0%top of R1 (wk low ’25-03-14, wk high ’25-06-20)

Trend at a glance

Trend Score (8–16 wk)
● Down
Score 44/100. Leads S&P and sector; below falling 40-wk.
Trading (10–20 day)
● Neutral
Above 50-day; daily RS vs S&P Est. Up.
Sluymer's view: No recent call: not named in the 15 reports reviewed (Aug 18 – Oct 13, 2026).
Watch this week: Fri Nov 6: breakout entry on a close above $72.78 (+4.0%); a Friday close below $63.97 (-8.6%) invalidates.
Rule-based demo inspired by Robert Sluymer's published framework; not RBC research or advice. Data: Yahoo Finance; levels computed from price data. Prepared Nov 3, 2026, 2:52 PM PT. Appendix on page 2.
APPENDIX · CMS · TECHNICAL TRADING SCORECARD

Scores · Trend 43.5

RS vs S&P (20) + sector (10)15.4 + 5.7 = 21.1 / 30
Structure (6 checks)5 / 30
Score = (RS + structure) × 100/6043.5 / 100
Raw state (Up ≥ 60 · Down < 45)Down
Confirmation (2 consecutive Fridays)confirmed Down
Trend (confirmed)Down
✖ Fri close above 40-wk SMA 0/6 · ✖ 40-wk SMA rising (4 wks) 0/4 · ✖ No lower high vs cycle high 0/5 · ✖ Fri close above 20-wk SMA 0/5 · ✔ Fri close above 200-wk (4-yr) SMA 5/5 · ✖ 4-mo SMA > 13-mo SMA (completed months, to Sep) 0/5
Weekly raw states: 09-25 Down → 10-02 Down → 10-09 Down → 10-16 Down → 10-23 Neutral → 10-30 Down. Coppock, band position, breadth and modifiers no longer enter the Trend score (Coppock chart below is reference only).

Scores · Trading 57.3

RS (S&P 20 + sector 10)20.0 + 4.3 / 30
Structure10 / 25
Coppock (daily) — positive but rolling over from >80th pctile6.2 / 25
Band position16.8 / 20
Raw57.3 (Neutral)
Modifiers (10-yr > 5% rising −3, seasonal −2)+0
Final57.3 Neutral
✔ Close above 50-day SMA 5/5 · ✖ 50-day SMA rising (10 d) 0/3 · ✖ Close above 100-day SMA 0/4 · ✖ Close above 200-day SMA 0/5 · ✖ 200-day SMA rising (20 d) 0/3 · ✔ No daily lower high (last two swing highs) 5/5

Relative state (weekly RS vs 16-wk SMA + 2-wk slope; daily RS vs 15-d SMA + 3-d slope; Neutral ±0.25%; phase price = next Fri / next close, benchmark flat)

Horizon · benchmarkStateRS vs SMARS chgPhase-transition price (CMS close needed)
Trend · S&P2 Early Up (+) →+2.84%+3.11%Est. Up ≥ 80.21 (+14.6%) · Early Up ≥ 67.91 · Est. Down < 67.55
Trend · XLU2 Early Up (−) →+0.46%-0.83%Est. Up ≥ 72.83 (+4.0%) · Early Up ≥ 69.90 · Est. Down < 69.53
Trading · S&P1 Established Up (+) →+3.01%+2.71%Est. Up ≥ 68.32 (-2.4%) · Est. Down < 52.65
Trading · XLU4 Early Down (+) ↓-0.50%+0.04%Est. Up ≥ 70.61 (+0.9%) · Est. Down < 66.64

Full bands (cluster rule: 2 or more tools within 3%; Δ vs 70.00)

BandRangeDistanceTools in the cluster
R375.50–76.45+7.9% to +9.2%wk high ’25-04-25 75.50 · wk high ’25-11-28 75.53 · wk high ’25-10-17 76.11 · wk high 07-31 76.39 · wk high ’25-04-04 76.45
R273.12–75.06+4.5% to +7.2%61.8% 73.12 · wk high ’25-08-22 74.14 · wk low 03-20 74.19 · wk high ’25-05-09 74.41 · 50% 74.50 · wk high ’25-08-08 74.94 · wk high 05-29 75.00 · wk high ’25-03-07 75.06
R170.94–72.78+1.3% to +4.0%wk low ’25-03-14 70.94 · wk high ’25-06-20 71.03 · wk high ’25-06-06 71.05 · wk low ’25-08-01 71.16 · wk high 2024-11-29 71.35 · … +6 more · wk high ’25-05-23 72.39 · wk high 2024-10-25 72.40 · wk high 08-21 72.44 · 200-day SMA 72.56 · 40-wk SMA 72.78
S167.71–69.76-0.3% to -3.3%wk low ’25-09-19 69.76 · wk high 09-11 69.36 · wk low 2024-10-11 68.96 · wk high ’25-01-24 68.94 · wk low 06-05 68.84 · … +1 more · wk low 01-09 68.64 · wk low ’25-06-27 68.41 · wk low ’25-05-30 68.37 · wk low ’25-04-11 68.15 · wk low ’25-05-16 67.71
S263.97–65.47-6.5% to -8.6%wk low 2024-12-20 65.47 · wk low ’25-02-07 65.17 · wk low 2024-11-08 65.09 · wk low ’25-01-17 63.97
ATH80.36+14.8%all-time high; Profit-Taking fallback when no 2-tool band sits above the Breakout (extensions no longer used)

Coppock, breadth and RS (reference only; not in the Trend score)

Stops & phase transitions

  • Tier 1 (trading stop): daily close < 67.71 (-3.3%): trading downgrades one state, re-anchor to S2 63.97–65.47.
  • Tier 2 (trend stop = Trend Breakdown / invalidation): Friday close < 63.97 (-8.6%): trend downgrades one state, re-anchor to the next lower level (none computed).
  • Trend vs S&P: Est. Up ≥ 80.21 (+14.6%) · above its 16-wk avg ≥ 67.91 · Est. Down < 67.55 (-3.5%) (next Friday, benchmark flat).
  • Trading vs S&P: Est. Up ≥ 68.32 · Est. Down < 52.65.

Sluymer context

  • Not named in the 15 reports reviewed (Aug 18 – Oct 13, 2026).

Notes & caveats

PAG U.S. Focus List alternative, entry card (treated like the US Watchlist). Holdings: issuer file as of 2026-10-14 (RBC PAG "Guided Portfolio Large Cap Equity Grid", last updated October 14, 2026 (u.s._focus_list_current.pdf; Focus List names, weights and Alternatives), Gmail (sc.assistant80@gmail.com), "USFL and CFL equity grids" from stephen.k.chang@rbc.com, Oct 21, 2026 3:20 PM PT; matches the Oct 14, 2026 U.S. Focus List Change Report); Grid Alternative (Utilities; no Focus List weight). Benchmarks: S&P 500 (20 pts) and XLU (10 pts). Trading items and bands use the Tue, Nov 3, 2026 close; trend uses the Fri, Oct 30 week. Entry levels: Buy Zone = breakout retest zone (BUY names only: from the broken level down to the floor of the resistance band it came from, or level −2%, whichever is tighter; a weekly close below = failed breakout); Breakout Buy Level = top of R1; Trend Breakdown (invalidation) = S2 floor on a Friday close; Profit-Taking = next resistance band above the breakout. Verdict: AVOID = Trend Down (confirmed on two Fridays) or Friday close below a falling 40-wk SMA; BUY = a weekly close above a Breakout Buy Level fixed from the prior week's data with ≥2 tools within 3% (most recent such breakout in the last 4 weeks), every Friday close since and the latest close still at or above it, and Trend not Down; WAIT = otherwise. Buy Zone is reference only. Coppock = 10-bar WMA of ROC(14)+ROC(11), standard settings used as a placeholder because his are unpublished; DAS is omitted. Zone = sign + 3-yr percentile; direction = 2 bars. SMAs are simple; swings are 5-bar extremes; the channel is a 2-yr log regression ±2σ. The breadth proxy is the % of 500 current S&P 500 members with a rising weekly Coppock; it has survivorship bias, is a regime input only, and no other stock was scored. Weights are our choices (playbook §10); the state rule matched 86% / 83% of his sector states in-sample. Data: Yahoo Finance (unadjusted); weight from the Portfolio Dashboard (PIM 11/2 EOD, read-only).